Real Estate Transfer Tax on Share-for-Share Exchanges under EU Law

In its judgment published on the 4th of June 2026, last Thursday, in Case C-837/24, Nova Iberomoldes, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled that a share-for-share exchange in Portugal involving the contribution of a majority of the voting rights in a real estate holding company to an acquiring company, in return for shares issued by the acquiring company, constitutes a restructuring operation falling within the scope of the exemption from indirect taxes under Article 5(1)(e) of Directive 2008/7/EC (12 February 2008) concerning indirect taxes on the raising of capital. Consequently, the ECJ held that such a transaction may not be subjected to real estate transfer tax (RETT).

The judgment is particularly relevant for Austria following (a) the expansion of the real estate transfer tax regime to indirect share transfers in real estate holding companies under the Budgetbegleitgesetz 2025 and (b) the generally lowering of the threshold for triggering real estate transfer tax when shares in real estate holding companies are transferred from 95% to 75%. The EJC judgment raises doubts as to whether the narrow exemption for group reorganisations contained in § 1(3)(5) Austrian RETT Act is compatible with EU law. Taxpayers involved in past or future restructuring transactions may therefore have grounds to invoke Directive 2008/7/EC directly and challenge the assessments of real estate transfer tax that conflict with the Directive’s mandatory exemption for restructuring operations.

Fact Situation

In Case C-837/24, the taxpayer, Nova Iberomoldes, was incorporated as a Portuguese public limited company. Its share capital was fully subscribed through contributions in kind consisting of shareholdings held by its sole shareholder in several companies. One of those companies, whose shares were transferred to the taxpayer and subsequently became wholly owned by it, held two immovable properties.

The Portuguese tax authorities took the view that the contribution did not satisfy the requirements for the application of a regime known as the ‘rules on tax neutrality’ and therefore assessed Portuguese real estate transfer tax. The taxpayer argued that the transaction constituted a contribution of capital within the meaning of Article 3(a) of Directive 2008/7/EC and that, pursuant to Article 5(1)(a) of that Directive, the formation of a capital company through such a contribution could not be subjected to any form of indirect taxation, such as real estate transfer tax.

Short Overview of Directive 2008/7/EC

Directive 2008/7/EC regulates, inter alia, the levying of indirect taxes on contributions of capital to capital companies and on restructuring operations involving capital companies.

Pursuant to Article 5 of Directive 2008/7/EC, Member States shall not subject capital companies to any form of indirect tax, including real estate transfer tax, in respect of, among others, contributions of capital and certain restructuring operations.

  • Contributions of capital under Article 3 of the Directive 2008/7/EC include, in particular, the formation of a capital company and increases in its capital through contributions of assets of any kind.

  • Restructuring operations under Article 4 of the Directive 2008/7/EC, among others, comprise mergers, demergers, as well as contributions in kind in exchange for the issuance of shares in the acquiring company, share-for-share exchanges where a majority of the voting rights in a capital company is contributed, and the transfer of all assets and liabilities of a subsidiary capital company to its parent capital company, where the subsidiary capital company is wholly owned by the parent capital company.

Notwithstanding Article 5, Article 6(1)(a) and 6(1)(b) of Directive 2008/7/EC permits Member States to impose:

  • duties on the transfer of securities, whether levied at a flat rate or otherwise; and

  • transfer duties, including land registration taxes, on the transfer to a capital company of businesses or immovable property situated within their territory.

Legal Assessment by the ECJ

  • The ECJ stated that Directive 2008/7/EC seeks to eliminate distortions of competition and obstacles to the free movement of capital, thereby ensuring the proper functioning of the internal market. To that end, Article 5(1)(a) and (e) prohibits Member States from subjecting capital companies to any form of indirect tax in respect of contributions of capital and restructuring operations. The court held that the transaction at issue constituted a restructuring operation within the meaning of Article 4(1)(b) of the Directive, as the shares acquired by Nova Iberomoldes represented a majority of the voting rights in other companies and were exchanged for securities in the acquiring company. Accordingly, Article 5(1)(e) precluded the imposition of any indirect tax (RETT) on such a transaction.

  • The court further clarified that Article 6(1)(a), applies only to independent transfers of securities and not to transfers forming an integral part of a restructuring operation. Since the transfer in question was incidental to such a restructuring operation, it fell outside that provision.

  • As regards Article 6(1)(b), the court held that it permits taxation only in cases involving a transfer of legal ownership of immovable property or businesses to a capital company. In the present case, no such transfer occurred, as the immovable property remained within the subsidiary. The argument that there was an economic transfer of the properties via the share transfer, which could be considered equivalent for tax purposes, and that the transaction should therefore be regarded as an effective transfer of immovable property from an economic perspective, was rejected by the ECJ. Even if an economic approach were relevant, the court held that in a group restructuring such as the present case, no transfer of immovable property would arise.

Impact on the Austrian Real Estate Transfer Tax Act

The decision is likely to impact the Austrian real estate transfer tax regime, which was recently amended by the Budgetbegleitgesetz 2025. The reform introduced taxation of indirect share transfers of at least 75% in real estate holding companies (if shares are transferred indirectly via upper-tier entities) and a relatively narrow exemption for group reorganisations under § 1(3)(5) RETT Act in this respect. Further, the reform generally reduced the threshold for triggering real estate transfer tax on share deals from 95% to 75%.

The exemption for group reorganizations applies to reorganisations within the meaning of the Austrian Reorganisation Tax Act (Umgründungssteuergesetz) and only excludes indirect share unifications or acquisitions when all parties belong to the same group. Binder Grösswang had already raised concerns regarding the narrow scope of the exemption in the public consultation of the underlying draft legislation of the Budgetbegleitgesetz 2025, arguing that the provision should, in principle, cover all reorganisations within a group.

In light of the new ECJ judgment, all indirect and, also, direct share unifications or acquisitions within the scope of a restructuring operation under Directive 2008/7/EC should be exempt from real estate transfer tax. Moreover, the exemptions under the Directive 2008/7/EC for restructuring operations do generally not require that the parties involved belong to the same group.

Accordingly, the narrow exemption under § 1(3)(5) RETT Act appears difficult to align with Directive 2008/7/EC. As a result, certain share unifications or acquisitions in restructuring scenarios may be subject to Austrian real estate transfer tax, although EU law requires an exemption, indicating a potential deficiency in the Austrian implementation of the Directive 2008/7/EC.

If EU directives have not been properly implemented, taxpayers may rely on their provisions directly, provided that the conditions for direct effect are met and a directive-conforming interpretation is not possible. According to the case-law of the ECJ (e.g., Case C-8/81, Becker), the direct effect of a directive provision requires the fulfilment of four conditions:

  • the directive has not been properly implemented into national law;

  • the implementation deadline has expired;

  • the provision in question is sufficiently clear, precise and unconditional; and

  • the provision confers rights on individuals vis-à-vis the State.

The conditions should be satisfied in the present case (BFG 18 July 2017, RV/3100906/2016); Articles 4 and 5 of Directive 2008/7/EC clearly prohibit the imposition of indirect taxes on restructuring operations. Accordingly, these provisions should be directly applicable, especially meaning that no real estate transfer tax should be levied on restructuring operations in scope of the Directive 2008/7/EC.

For past restructuring operations not covered by § 1(3)(5) RETT Act but qualifying as restructuring operations under the Directive 2008/7/EC, retroactive correction to a nil assessment might be possible under § 201 Austrian Federal Fiscal Code (Bundesabgabenordnung). For future filings, taxpayers should be able to rely on the new ECJ judgment and Directive 2008/7/EC, provided the nature of the restructuring operation is properly disclosed.

Please note: This blog is for general information purposes only and in no way constitutes legal advice from Binder Grösswang Rechtsanwälte GmbH. The blog cannot replace individual legal advice. Binder Grösswang Rechtsanwälte GmbH accepts no liability of any kind for the content and accuracy of the blog.